January 22, 2010

fashion, basically. also, TEAM CONAN

This morning Tanya Gold published an article in The Guardian entitled "Why I Hate Fashion." SPOILER ALERT: it's about why she hates fashion. I suggest reading it before continuing reading this post, because then you get more of an idea of what this whole discussion is about. Also, I hope you're sitting down. Get cozy. Use the toilet real quick, so you don't have to get up and go in the middle.

I can't say I fully disagree with everything she said. I hate the size issue, I hate the commercialism, I hate 14-year-old models being told to lose weight so they can look sexy in a dress made for women twice their age. The problem, though, is how she is so general-ALL of it is uncreative and evil, apparently. But it's a broad subject. Criticizing parts of it (poorly, might I add) is understandable, but putting Yohji Yamamoto in the same category as a magazine about cellulite, dating tips, and makeup is not. Oh, and speaking of Yohji Yamamoto? He hates fashion, too. Oh, and speaking of makeup? Neither editors Katie Grand, editor of Love, or Anna Dello Russo, editor of Vogue Nippon, (you know, Vogue, the magazine Ms. Gold said she spits at and sometimes rips up) wear any.

I am sort of used to the occasional "Why would you waste your prodigal, wiz kid, Jay-Leno-would-probably-sit-you-on-his-lap-and-exclaim-'kids these days! They can use commas!'-type GENIUS (that's me, the genius!) on something as frivolous as fashion?" email. I am also, luckily and gratefully, used to the occasional "I don't like fashion at all and I have never taken an interest in it but I still love your blog and like what you're doing" email, as well. And while we are on the topic of Leno, COCO ALL THE WAY. Tonight was a sad night.

It's refreshing to me that those who can see that all the supposedly "fashion"-oriented magazines and reality TV shows are BS can still appreciate a fashion blog, and for that I'm very thankful. It's not, I don't think, a very difficult thing to do. But then there's the "fashion is stupid!" mindset. The people I know in real life that share this view hate it when clothes are just about being attractive -- then they scoff when I show them the work of any designer whose work is out of the ordinary or not focused on making its wearer look sexy. Tanya Gold, too, says that she "can look at the clothes on the catwalk now and laugh at their imbecility." So, you hate fashion that is soulless and you hate fashion that required of the designer thought and emotion. That's pretty cynical. Conan says don't be cynical. AND CONAN IS RIGHT.

You know, in the beginning of The September Issue, Anna Wintour says she thinks some people mock fashion because they are intimidated by it. And she's right. Yeah, it's snobby, but you know what? So is turning up your nose at a runway collection because you thinks it's weird and you just don't get it. This, in fact, makes the nose-turner-upper not too different from those horrible "fashion" magazines - dismissing something because it's strange. How very narrow-minded.

Ms. Gold speaks about how she discovered fashion at 13 and then dressed in a way she knew she was supposed to dress. "How I enchanted. How I belonged. I thought I looked just like the effortlessly beautiful girls at school. Except I didn't. And, very soon, I realised that I didn't. All that weekend job money and childish angst and still I looked like me. That was the first seduction – and the first betrayal." I don't believe Ms. Gold "discovered" fashion; she discovered middle school and teenagerdom. She said that before that, she dressed as Andy Pandy and was happier.

I find the idea of dressing as Andy Pandy pretty awesome. It's creative and it's fun, and that sounds fashionable to me. What Tanya Gold and many others, including myself, hate is the everyone-has-to-look-the-same-and-also-sexy philosophy, which is NOT fashion.

This is by no means written with the intentions of a personal attack on Ms. Gold, but rather, a kind of response to this idea that I see coming up often. I think that the problem with fashion isn't fashion, but how others decide to see it. The same "fashion" magazines that offer advice about pleasing men might decide that fashion isn't for overweight people, but it's Tanya Gold's fault for believing it, and if she really wanted to have fun with clothes she could. Same goes for the idea that clothes HAVE to make you look sexy. Not if you don't want to! Isn't that amazing!

I invite these folks to read a constructive runway review by Cathy Horyn, Robin Givhan, Suzy Menkes, Hilary Alexander, or Lynn Yaeger. Look at the works of Comme des Garcons, Rodarte, Issey Miyake, Alexander McQueen, or Vivienne Westwood, at the very least. Read a magazine that has not one word about plastic surgery or dieting, or at least, ignore those parts and appreciate the art (Lula, i-D, Russh, Dazed and Confused, Pop, Love, Vogue, Bazaar, W, to name a few). Be open-minded.

Her article was essentially pointless, and I guess my post is, as well. Tanya Gold will still hate fashion, my friends will still question the loyalty I have for it, and I'm pretty sure that most of the people that come to this blog and will see it come because they already know everything I just spent too much time saying, anyway. Still, I felt compelled to write it, for whatever reason, and will go to bed, my brain swirling with thoughts. I love discussing and thinking about fashion philosophy, and I wish the "it's supposed to make you look attractive" one would vanish.

Read: Personal attacks on Tanya Gold, be it about her writing abilities or physical appearance or age, are irrelevant, unnecessary, and will be deleted.

412 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   401 – 412 of 412
The Escondido Hipster said...

very much trying to promote fashion, art and fun through blog in the tragically un hip town of escondido california.. i appreciate this post very much

Jade said...

a mi en lo personal la moda era una de mis ultimas prioridades yo solo me usaba la ropa que me hacia sentir bien pero cuando empece a leer tus artículos e interesarme mas en la moda descubrí lo divertido, atrevido y sexy que es estar a la moda y ahora me siento mucho mejor¡¡

mohsin said...

Hey hi,my name is Mohsin ali, n I m a fashion designer, I admire ur sence of style! I just discovered ur blog, n I m very happy about this very fashion discovery, I was just thinking the same things, but I thought the criticism would just be here in Pakistan about great n true fashion, it's sad but it's ur inner happiness n satisfaction that matters by wearing what u want to wear! Wish u all the very best!

Hanna said...

I've been waiting to find this article!

Fashion is an art and People love art. It's easy to love a collection and want to make clothes and not get into yourself. It's hard to go buy and wear fashion without getting into yourself. Other arts have this downside too. For example, a fancy painting in a house and the host shows it off to guests. It was expensive and possibly pretty and this reflects on them. When you get clothes you like, you feel pretty in them. Sometimes all these pretty and love feeling mix together. Then starts materialism. I guess what it comes down to is why you think they're pretty on you or if you're comfortable in the clothes. There are just so many things to think about!!!

folknfables said...

Wow. Spitting and tearing up Vogue? That's so extreme and really tacky. I didn't get a chance to read the original article but from what you're saying it was really harsh. It's not black and white, where you either love fashion/ worship it or hate it. it's about personality and even people who say they hate fashion and the industry still buy into it because it's a necessity. very "narrow-minded" indeed.

예지 said...

하하! 전 한국 사람이에요 저는 영어를 싫어하죠 하지만, 저는 패션을 매우 사랑해요! 그리고 당신을 존경하죠!

Angela said...

*standing ovation* Bravo Tavi, well written & eloquent as always.

Love

Angela

songbird said...

i am a relatively new blogger,a novice at all things fashion..but the point about "fashion isn't for overweight people" struck a chord because i am fat and i like dressing up and i have formed a recent lookbook page posting my looks.i like when people don't follow these stupid rules rather than wearing whatever they like.fashion is art and you live your life in it.i love art and i love open-minded people.
htt://flysongbird.blogspot.com

mjewelh said...

We provide you the Hottest styles and a large number of selection with fast shipping. Browse a large selection of Hot party dresses for styling. you can Find the perfect and excellent sexy dress, bandage dress, red dress, or sleek white party dress. All are at low prices and flexible for you.

stylish accessories
cheap sunglasses
sexy clubwear
stylish sunglasses

M.Usman said...

You will find miles of white sandy beaches at Holkham and Cromer, with beautiful campsites a plenty for your motorhome, some situated right on the beach. If you are looking for a bit of history look no further than Norwich with its medieval churches and stunning Norman cathedral and castle.derbyshire campervan hire

Thomas Edison said...

congratulations guys, quality information you have given!!! mori lee julietta

Thomas Edison said...

congratulations guys, quality information you have given!!! mori lee julietta

«Oldest ‹Older   401 – 412 of 412   Newer› Newest»